Motex
MotexSecond additional petition · Annex

Second additional petition · Annex

Can you sue a river?

Motex Team · November 10, 2026 · Chilean law

In a made-up country, someone who loses their house in a flood sues the river. In Chile, the useful question is a different one: who had the duty of care, and whether they met it.

1The idea: suing the river

In Clamzoria, the essay's first country, rivers, trees and rocks are legal persons. If a flood destroys a house, the owner sues the river. An administrator appointed by the court manages the river's income —tolls, water sales— until the judgment is paid.

In Clamzoria, even a tree can end up behind bars.

2What the Civil Code says

In Chile, water is a thing, not a subject: declares all waters to be national property for public use. A thing does not pay damages. Whoever caused the harm does: requires a person who has committed a "delict or quasi-delict" that harmed another to compensate.

Those two words do not mean here what they mean in criminal law. defines them: a delict is an act committed with intent to harm, and a quasi-delict is a blameworthy act committed without intent to harm. Put simply: you do not need to have wanted the harm to owe compensation. Carelessness is enough.

What creates no liability is harm that no one could resist: force majeure, which defines as an unforeseen event that cannot be resisted, giving an earthquake as an example.

So if a mudslide comes down a ravine and into a house, the ravine cannot be sued. And if it was an unforeseen event that could not be resisted, no one is liable for it. The question the law can answer is a different one: whether someone had a duty to prevent or reduce the harm, and was careless in meeting it.

3The San Carlos de Apoquindo mudslide

The question is not theoretical. On October 8, 2026, a mudslide came down through San Carlos de Apoquindo, in Las Condes, and affected hundreds of homes. On October 26 there was a second event, concentrated in the Honda and Apoquindo ravines. A month later, the municipality is still clearing streets, ravines and drains, and the Ministry of Public Works still has machinery in the ravines (La Tercera, November 9, 2026). For an affected resident, what matters is not what the ravine did. It is what each of those public bodies was supposed to do, before and after.

4When the one responsible is an organization

Whoever had that duty can be a person, a company or the State. It can sound odd to blame an organization for something a person did, but the law does it all the time. If a cook prepares food badly, the customer who gets sick can sue the restaurant: makes employers liable for the acts of their employees.

For the State, the law gives carelessness its own name: failure of service (falta de servicio). makes public bodies liable for the harm they cause through failure of service, and the Corte Suprema (Supreme Court) reads it as .

One case involves the Navy. A corporal lost his left arm trying to remove a round stuck in a saluting cannon. The Navy had taken no safety measures and had no protocol for that task: that was its carelessness. Because the armed forces fall outside Article 42, the Supreme Court judged it directly under Article 2314 of the Civil Code, and recalled that legal persons are capable of fault even though they lack a will of their own. It ordered the State to pay him 15 million pesos in non-pecuniary damages, an amount it reduced because the corporal himself used unsuitable tools (Olivares Henríquez v. Fisco de Chile, ).

Another involves a municipality. In Puerto Montt, a 12-year-old boy riding a bicycle on the sidewalk fell into a hole 1.30 meters deep. The municipality argued that the hole was part of the storm-water system, and that repairing it was a ministry's job. The Supreme Court answered that it did not matter who had to repair it: the municipality administers the street, and it had to monitor it and warn of the hazard. Not doing so was the failure of service, and it had to pay (Irarrázaval Reyes v. Municipalidad de Puerto Montt, ). Accidents like this still happen: in October 2019, a boy playing soccer in Quillaipe, about 30 kilometers from Puerto Montt, fell into a well at least ten meters deep and had to be rescued by firefighters (BioBioChile, October 12, 2019).

5In short

In Clamzoria, the damage from the mudslide is paid by the rains themselves, out of whatever they managed to produce. In Chile, whoever had the duty of care and did not meet it pays. If no one had that duty, or whoever had it met it, harm caused by nature has no one to be charged to.